Trading and Brokerage: Trading with Financial Securities

Trading and brokerage represent one of the most significant business lines within investment banking. These activities involve the buying and selling of financial securities either using the bank’s own capital or on behalf of its clients. Together, they play a crucial role in shaping market efficiency, liquidity, and the profitability of financial institutions.

At a fundamental level, trading and brokerage operations enable the flow of capital across financial markets, facilitate price discovery, and support investors ranging from individuals to large institutions. 

Photo created by Author

Broadly, trading activities can be classified into two main categories: proprietary trading and brokerage services.

Proprietary Trading vs. Brokerage

Proprietary Trading

Proprietary trading refers to transactions where a bank uses its own funds to purchase financial securities with the objective of selling them later at a higher price. The profit earned from these activities directly accrues to the bank.

Investment banks possess a competitive advantage in proprietary trading due to their deep understanding of financial markets, real-time access to market information, and advanced analytical capabilities. These institutions continuously monitor market movements, interest rate trends, macroeconomic indicators, and geopolitical developments to identify short-term profit opportunities.

A key contributor to successful proprietary trading is the research department. Investment banks employ highly specialized analysts and strategists who generate market forecasts, asset valuations, and trading ideas. Their insights enable proprietary traders to make informed decisions, manage risk effectively, and enhance their overall trading performance.

Brokerage Services

Brokerage, on the other hand, involves executing buy and sell orders on behalf of clients rather than trading with the bank’s own capital. In this model, banks earn revenue through a markup or spread—the difference between the price at which a security is bought and sold.

In theory, brokerage operations aim to maintain a quasi-neutral (Near-Zero) market exposure, meaning the bank seeks to minimize directional risk. Profitability in brokerage largely depends on transaction volume rather than price movements. Higher trading volumes typically result in higher fee income, even if individual margins are relatively small.

Contribution to Bank Profitability

Trading and brokerage activities are among the most important revenue generators for major investment banks. For firms such as Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, these operations account for more than one-third of total revenues.

In the case of universal banks, this proportion may appear diluted due to significant interest income from traditional lending activities. Nevertheless, trading remains a critical profit engine across both investment banks and universal banks, especially during periods of high market volatility and active investor participation.

Role of Investment Banks in Market Liquidity

Investment banks play a vital role in maintaining liquidity in financial markets. One of their key functions in this context is market making.

Market making involves continuously quoting buy and sell prices for specific securities and being willing to transact at those prices. By holding inventories of securities, banks ensure that investors can execute trades even in less liquid markets.

This function is particularly important for securities that do not trade frequently. Since holding such instruments exposes banks to price volatility and inventory risk, they are compensated through wider bid-ask spreads. These spreads reward banks for providing liquidity and absorbing short-term market risk.

Without active market makers, many financial markets would experience wider price fluctuations, delayed transactions, and reduced investor confidence.

Types of Securities Traded

Modern investment banks trade a wide range of financial instruments across multiple asset classes. These include:

• Equities – common and preferred shares of companies
• Fixed Income Securities – government bonds, corporate bonds, and money market instruments
• Derivatives – complex financial contracts whose value is derived from underlying assets

Derivative instruments play an increasingly important role in trading activities. They vary significantly in structure and purpose. Some derivatives are primarily used for hedging, enabling corporations and investors to manage risks associated with interest rates, foreign exchange, or commodity prices. Others are used for speculation, aiming to profit from anticipated market movements.

Common derivative instruments include:

• Forwards
• Futures
• Options
• Swaps

The extensive use of derivatives highlights the sophistication of modern trading and the importance of robust risk management systems within financial institutions.

Conclusion

Trading and brokerage are core pillars of investment banking, driving profitability, supporting market liquidity, and enabling efficient capital allocation. Proprietary trading allows banks to leverage their expertise and research capabilities for direct profit, while brokerage services focus on facilitating client transactions at scale.

As financial markets continue to evolve, these activities will remain central to the functioning of global financial systems. A deeper examination of trading strategies, risk management practices, and regulatory frameworks will further enhance the understanding of this critical investment banking function.